SUBSCRIBE|ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION




EDITORIAL
Ban—Empty-handed But Wiser
Monday, July 6, 2009

COMMENTS (12)
RECOMMEND (84)
E-MAIL
PRINT

Although he left Burma empty-handed without any visible sign of progress or concession from the Burmese junta, United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon’s visit was by no means pointless.

Through his official visit to the military-ruled country he should have discovered a deeper understanding of how far the international community—under the name of the United Nations—can expect to go in its current mission to facilitate democratization in Burma through national reconciliation.

Ban's talks with the Naypyidaw regime—and primarily junta chief Snr-Gen Than Shwe—focused on three important issues: gaining the release of all political prisoners including democracy icon Aung San Suu Kyi; resumption of dialogue between the military government and its opposition; and creating the conditions for credible elections.

The UN secretary-general’s hopes were quickly dashed. He was even refused a visit with detained opposition leader Suu Kyi.

However, in forcing Than Shwe to show his cards, Ban is left in no doubts as to what degree of flexibility the regime might be prepared to go to—none.

The UN chief had no qualms about publicly criticizing Burma’s military rulers before he left from the country. "I believe the government of Myanmar [Burma] has lost a unique opportunity to show its commitment to a new era of political openness," he said in an emotive speech at Rangoon’s Drug Elimination Museum to 500 state officials, diplomats, INGO staff and local pressmen.

Of course, no one expected much from the visit, and observers noted once again that the junta would manipulate it for propaganda purposes. But at least Ban should have earned the respect of the international community for confronting the junta and for speaking the truth.

Now the gloves are off and Ban can concentrate more forcefully on what he has called "a very tough mission."

At a pit stop in the Thai capital, Bangkok, Ban met with Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva, and told reporters that to show his commitment to moving the Burma issue forward, his special envoy, Ibrahim Gambari, will shortly convene the so-called Group of Friends on Myanmar, a gathering of countries supporting greater dialogue.

However, Ban must now know that words without teeth will not worry the Burmese generals.

Naypyidaw has proved to the world that no matter how many resolutions the UN passes—even dragging Burma before the 15-nation UN Security Council—the junta will not willingly release the 2,100 political prisoners in the country, least of all Suu Kyi.

We will all be closely watching the UN secretary-general’s next step.

Ban’s visit may not have achieved any visible outcome, but the people of Burma will remember what he promised: "I have come to show the unequivocal shared commitment of the United Nations to the people of Myanmar. I am here today to say: Myanmar – you are not alone."



COMMENTS (12)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

yellowcake Wrote:
13/07/2009
Obviously, Ban has run out of carrots and only sticks remain in his hands. He shall have to use them wisely on the stubborn Junta.

MS Wrote:
09/07/2009
Mike, you are utterly right and much centered. As known, before militarism starting from 88, Burma was once ruled under BSPP for 26 years. During that reign, many religious minorities were suppressed and stripped of almost everything through nationalization, denaturalization and extermination, but these Bama majority (ruling) people were not concerned about state injustice and tyranny against those innocent minority citizens. As a result, they are today paying a heavy price for their silence. Likewise, the international community will pay in the future if they neglect Burma’s cruel regime. As the saying goes “An injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere”.

Linn Wrote:
08/07/2009
I appreciate his commitment to the people of Myanmar.We are hoping for the next step.
"words without teeth will not worry the Burmese generals." The next step must be to reinforce words with teeth. Only this will worry the Burmese generals.

Abuasfa Wrote:
08/07/2009
I don't know whether Than Shwe can understand English or not, but I am sure he doesn't listen to either Burmese people or Ban Ki-moon .

SY Alam Wrote:
08/07/2009
Than Shwe used his two ears when he listened to Ban Ki-moon. Ban Ki-moon's voice went in from one side and came out from the other. Nothing remained inside. Now, he is empty again as usual. I am Sorry for my fellow Burmese. He is not listening to us either.

Kyaw Win Wrote:
08/07/2009
Bravo, Mr. Ban!! At least you could meet and talk to the junta directly with your three tough demands for the sake of the people of Myanmar. I admire you for having tried with great effort (hoping your next move will be more forceful than this). I believe you did a great job for the people of Myanmar!

newmillennium3000 Wrote:
08/07/2009
I am not being sarcastic, but it is so true, though. I believe Ban when he said Myanmar is not alone. Of course, it is not. North Korea is with it. The junta is trying to approach Iran. Than Shwe should not worry about the Chinese backing off. The Russian will take care of them also.

nono Wrote:
07/07/2009
Yes Myanmar is not alone. It has friends like N.Korea, Russia, China and India etc. If you have those kinds of friend, you will never care about the UN. Those friends are helping the generals but they never think about the citizens.

Annie Gofish Wrote:
07/07/2009
It should have been clear to Mr. Gambari long ago that his trips to Burma were pointless and that the only thing the Secretary General would accomplish by going there would be to learn first hand that the thugs who run "Myanmar" regard the international community, except those who feed their military machines and line their pockets, with disdain.

Healthcare and education warrant two percent of the generals' annual budget for their country. It's all an average family can do is to feed themselves. Fear and anger lurk behind most of the people's serene faces. Naypyidaw, which I have seen with my own eyes, is not surprisingly a Potemkin village.

The whole of Myanmar is a political prison.

QQ Wrote:
07/07/2009
Ban and the international community had better plan to grab Than Shwe by the neck and point a gun at his head.

The junta will never release Daw ASSK and others. They will never make progress on the economy of the country. Instead, they want the people to be deaf and blind and make everyone suffer so much hardship that nobody has time to think about politics. Besides, they will be shot dead if they open their mouths.

This is their road map to send the Burmese people to the graveyard, not towards democracy.

Their own road map is to use the money earned from the people's resources to buy guns from China and Russia to protect themselves, and to get health care in Singapore when they are sick.

We don't know how long the world will let them continue these atrocities at the expense of the lives and poverty of the Burmese people.


mike Wrote:
07/07/2009
Excuse me for commenting like a war monger but the only way to cure Burma is to physically oust the generals. There may be a little bloodshed, but far less misery & blood than Tan Shwe & his thugs will ultimately shed. The problem is no one wants to take responsibility for the unjustified criticism that will arise if they go in.

These rulers have a very weak army and they could be overthrown by someone like Luxembourg or Lichtenstein. The Chinese are even backing off.

Someone should do it now.

Tan Shwe and his cronies are hoping that Su Kyi will fall ill in prison and die, thus making them less than directly responsible.

World Karma is not good right now


timothy Wrote:
07/07/2009
Ban has said that Burmese people are not alone. I wonder whether Than Shwe understands this? Now the UN has the duty to protect the defenceless citizens if the state fails to act appropriately. The junta is doing the opposite. They harm their own citizens. Ban also mentioned the UN charter. Burma is one of the signatories.



More Articles in This Section

bullet Engagement? It's Asean’s Shame

bullet Asean’s Never-ending Struggle for Relevance

bullet Halfway to a Handshake

bullet Don’t Let the Junta off the Hook

bullet Impotent China

bullet Tension in the North

bullet Webb’s Tangled Message

bullet Lay Off the Lady

bullet Clinton’s Flawed Burma Message

bullet The World is Ready for a President Aung San Suu Kyi


 

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.