SUBSCRIBE|ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION




Propaganda and the Burmese Media


By WAI MOE Wednesday, September 9, 2009

COMMENTS (7)
RECOMMEND (135)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT

Burma’s notorious censorship board, called the Press Scrutiny and Registration Division, has allowed a private Rangoon journal to publish translated versions of articles that have appeared in the international media.

The Voice Weekly published translated versions of op-ed articles on Burmese politics from The Washington Post and The New York Times, an unusual event in Burma.

A bicycle taxi driver reads the newspaper. (Photo: AP)

Burmese readers inside Burma were surprised when they saw the articles from two of America’s leading newspapers, several readers told The Irrawaddy.

“I was surprised because I know our country has serious censorships problem,” said a high school teacher in Rangoon who regularly buys and reads weekly journals. 

One of the op-ed articles that appeared in The Voice Weekly, originally published in The Washington Post, was written by a Burmese historian, Thant Myint-U. The article “Let’s Talk to Burma. China Sure Is.” called for more engagement with the military regime in Burma. The translated version appeared in The Voice’s Aug. 31 edition.

In the Sept. 7 edition, controversial US Sen Jim Webb’s commentary, “We Can’t Afford to Ignore Myanmar,” originally published in The New York Times on August 25, was translated and published in The Voice Weekly

Editors in Rangoon said that Burma’s censorship board decided to publish these articles because they favored the lifting of economic sanctions. Other Rangoon-based journals did not publish the articles.

The Voice Weekly is edited by Nay Win Maung, who also publishes Living Color magazine. Living Color began publishing under the blessing of the former intelligence spy chief Gen Khin Nyunt. Dr Ye Naing Win, the son of Gen Khin Nyunt, is a close associate of Nay Win Maung.
 
The Washington Post once described Nay Win Maung as “a son of a military officer who was brought up among Burma's military elites, giving him good connections to military insiders.” 

The Voice Weekly regularly publishes articles praising the coming election in 2010 and the regime’s “road map” to democracy. It is not known if the publication has been ordered to publish such articles or acts on its own editorial policy.

However, some editors and journalists have said that there is a little more freedom in the publication of articles now.

Recently, journalists in Rangoon spotted the name of the late poet Tin Moe mentioned in a Rangoon publication. The poet laureate left for exile and died a few years ago in the US. A strong supporter of Aung San Suu Kyi and the democracy movement, he wrote hundreds of poems critical of the regime and since then, his name has not been allowed to appear in local media.

“U Tin Moe’s name was allowed to be published recently. I think the censorship board permitted his name in media…because he had passed away,” said a writer in Rangoon who asked for anonymity.

Some journalists said that after Maj Tint Swe took over the censorship board, the local media have a little more breathing space than before. Tint Swe himself writes articles and poems. One of his pen-names is Ye Yint Tint Swe.

The censorship board is now under the Ministry of Information. In the past, Ministry of Home Affairs and the military intelligence service controlled the board and monitored publications.

In spite of strict draconian rules and censorship regulations, Burma has more than 200 weekly and monthly publications. Some selected journals close to key officials are profitable. Many others struggle financially and are under heavy surveillance.

According to the Paris-based media watchdog Reporters without Borders, Burma’s freedom of press is at the very bottom in the world, ranking 170 out of 172 countries.

A recent example of muzzling the press freedom was that of a Rangoon-based private journal called the Phoenix that was banned in August after it repeatedly ran articles that were ordered to be removed by the censorship board.

A woman editor in Rangoon, when asked about press freedom and the regime’s favoritism of some publications, said: “There is no change in the freedom of the Burmese media. On all translated articles and reports that we want to publish, the censorship board has the final say and it will remove them if they don’t like them. But if these stories and op-ed pieces are in line with regime policy, they will allow them to be published.”



COMMENTS (7)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

plan B Wrote:
11/09/2009
Let's see; absolutely no news were found to favor anything other than sanctions, invasions, vilification, etc, for the past 20+ years.

Ko Wai Moe,

Instead of portraying as propaganda at least you could have suggested that SPDC is now opened to engagement.

Using Press Freedom:
1) Again diminish SPDC to a status of simple oppressors to be dealt with Banana Republic style policy proven to be bad.
2) Disservice to author like Than Myint_U to a pro SPDC status without explicitly stated.
3) As though Webb different view promoted by SPDC is somehow wrong.

SPDC is not consist of some buffoons. Everything done were done with a clear determination and purpose.

If Irrawaddy will point out more critically why SPDC is touting these articles. Maybe we all can learn more.

Otherwise it will be another anti-SPDC, pro status quo appeasing article similar to this
http://irrawaddy.org/article.php?art_id=16633

Salai Biak Wrote:
11/09/2009
A significant improvement of the media inside the country. It showed how persuasive diplomacy works in non-western countries. If you regard the Burmese regime as your enemy, you get reversal. But if you regard them as your brother, you are more likely to persuade them to change their (stubborn) behavior. Keep going Dr. Thant, and Jim.

soethane Wrote:
10/09/2009
It's important to note that the versions in English published outside are not the same as the censored Burmese versions published inside. And I could be wrong but I dont think its Thant Myint U 's Washington Post article that was translated and published but his interview in the Asia Times. Read the two versions and you will see - his criticisms of the government, the ASSK trial, etc are not there in the Burmese version.

LuuSoeLay Wrote:
10/09/2009
Certainly more propaganda favoring the junta will be published as expected. One can predict that DASSK will be released from house arrest just before the election, just as a propaganda ploy. The junta will make sure that her name will not appear in the ballot.

Moe Aung Wrote:
10/09/2009
'It is not known if the publication has been ordered to publish such articles or acts on its own editorial policy.'

Pretty sure they were actually 'asked' to publish these articles.

Yangontha Wrote:
09/09/2009
Congratulations to Thant Myint U and Jim Webb, who have been selected by the Voice Weekly or Weakly, for their great contributions towards the Regime's longevity! May both of you be able change the history of Burma for the next generations.

Danu Maung Wrote:
09/09/2009
Dr. Nay Win Maung is the editor-in-chief of the Voice' journal and 'Living Color' magazine. In spite of his connections with his classmate and one time influential person like Ye Naing Win, he privately criticizes the military regime and his articles were severely censored. He is one of initiators of 'the Third Path' - those who are unhappy with the present political status but accept the military's constitutional process so that a Constitutional government would dilute the power of the Generals.








Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

More Articles in This Section


bullet NDF Leaders Told to Appeal Past Treason Charges

bullet New US Law Could Force PTTEP Disclosure

bullet US Senators Want UN Investigation of Burma

bullet Thai Minister's Statement Spreads Fear in Camps

bullet Burma's Generals Meet North Korea's FM

bullet USDP Constitution Maintains Junta's Policies

bullet USDP Assigns Constituencies to Ministers

bullet NLD Members Meet ILO Representative in Rangoon

bullet Burmese Rank No. 1 in Malaysia Detention Center Deaths

bullet US Wants Burma-North Korea 'Transparency'


 

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Burmese Elections 2010 |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.