SUBSCRIBE|ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION




Burma’s Amnesty Announcement Draws Skepticism


By WAI MOE Tuesday, July 14, 2009

COMMENTS (8)
RECOMMEND (52)
E-MAIL
PRINT

Burmese dissidents are treating with caution an announcement by Burma’s United Nations ambassador that preparations are being made to release an unknown number of prisoners before the 2010 election.

UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon told reporters in New York on Monday that the Burmese permanent representative at the UN, Than Swe, had announced that “at the request of the secretary-general in Myanmar [Burma], the Myanmar government is processing to grant amnesty to prisoners on humanitarian grounds and with a view to enabling them to participate in the 2010 general elections.”

A bird's eye view of Insein prison. (Photo: Nic Dunlop)
Ban told reporters: “This is encouraging, but I have to continue to follow up how they will implement all the issues raised during my visit.”

At the headquarters of the opposition National League for Democracy (NLD) in Rangoon, spokesman Nyan Win pointed out that Than Swe’s announcement made no reference to political prisoners.

“We should carefully read the text of the ambassador. He did not say the junta will release political prisoners,” Nyan Win said. “He just said the junta would grant amnesty to prisoners on humanitarian grounds. So I do not think the comment was different from previous ones.”

According to human rights groups, the junta keeps more than 2,100 political prisoners behind bars. The number of political prisoners has doubled since crackdowns on monk-led demonstrators in late 2007.

Burma’s most famous political prisoner, Aung San Suu Kyi, is currently on trial in Rangoon, charged with violating the terms of her house arrest order. There have been suggestions that the regime intends to keep her in detention or even in jail at least until the 2010 general election has been held.

Bo Kyi, joint-secretary of the Thailand-based Assistance Association of Political Prisoners (AAPP), a Burmese human rights group focusing on political prisoner issues, told The Irrawaddy on Tuesday that the Burmese ambassador’s statement  was “the old song” and “a kind of trick” to confuse the international community.

“If the junta has the political will to release prisoners, they should withdraw the charge against Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and release her and all political prisoners,” said Bo Kyi, a former political prisoner.

“The junta often declares an amnesty, but then only a few political prisoners are among those freed. We should be aware that the junta has never kept its word,” he said.

“Political prisoners, including Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, are political pawns in the junta’s international playground.”  

The regime released 6,313 prisoners in February, saying the amnesty was for humanitarian reasons and to enable those freed “to participate in fair elections to be held in 2010.” However, there were only 31 political prisoners among them.

In the previous amnesty, in September 2008, the regime freed 9,002 prisoners, saying it wanted to “turn them into citizens to be able to participate in building a new nation”.  But only nine political prisoners, including Win Tin, a prominent NLD leader, were included in the amnesty.

In an amnesty in November 2007 to mark the conclusion of the National Convention, the junta released 8,585 prisoners. Twenty political prisoners were among them.

After the downfall of former Prime Minister Gen Khin Nyunt and the dismantling of his Military Intelligence in 2004, the junta granted an amnesty for more than 14,000 prisoners. They included 60 political prisoners, including prominent dissident Min Ko Naing—who is now back in jail. 

All political prisoners, who were released in amnesties, were near the end of the prison terms. 



COMMENTS (8)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

KKK Wrote:
16/07/2009
Another big lie. What can we expect from the liars? Nothing. Posting your comments and opinions on The Irrawaddy will not change the regime and Burma. Get the guns and take the lives of the junta and its cronies. That will change the regime and Burma.

metanu Wrote:
15/07/2009
Who wants to be bullied for the umpteenth time?Mr. Ban, did you forget the Junta always maintains that "there are no poitical prisoners in Myanmar," so how could they freed them. How could the Junta move towards democracy from a shameful, undemocratic constitution? Go back Mr. Ban,look at your wrongs and stop using your hope to legitimize 2010 election!

Kaw Thaw Wrote:
15/07/2009
Granting amnesty and releasing political prisoners are just a part of the political game played on the world stage by the Burmese regime to ease international pressure. They have done it in the past. And they have got warm reactions from all sides. It is very simple but it works well for the regime.

Fee Man Wrote:
15/07/2009
It just seems to be another empty promise, as we have witnessed broken promises made by this regime over and over.

NN Wrote:
15/07/2009
The international community organisations should have learnt that the junta always makes empty promise, tends to bully and never keep its word.Therefore, never believe in them. We must allow ourselves to get bullied for once.If you let yourself be bullied twice, it is our fault.
But one thing that makes me happy is the Ban said that without participation or free campaigning, the election will not be credible and will be illegal.
Enough is enough with the junta's words and promises. Just continue as far as you can go because people in Myanmar have nothing beyond zero. It has been zero since 1962.
Even if Daw Aung San Suu Kyi is allowed freely to participate in the election, the result might be manipulated by the junta, as before. It is necessary to be far sighted whenever you deal with the junta, which has no moral and ethical value.
If the international community does not release its grasp on the junta we hope that one day the junta will be brought under control.

Ursus Wrote:
15/07/2009
The junta has never kept word and it will be the same old story this time. It seems that they will release a few hundred petty criminals in order to clear space to imprison more political opponents before elections.

The UN, the world leaders and the Burmese people already know about this deceoitful practice.

Old Veteran Wrote:
15/07/2009
The announcement of an amnesty by the junta's UN representative will definetly draw skepticism from the global community, because it has been fooled many times before when common criminals were the majority of prisoners released in previous amnesties. This was seen as childish and deceitful political manoeuvering. Gen. Than Shwe should do better this time around if he doesn't want to be seen as a cunning despot. This is his last chance to save his face.
Burma as a member of the global community should not be seen as a foolish nation, and the Tatmadaw as a regular national army should not to be seen as a ruthless band of paid soldiers. In both cases all Burmese are put to shame just because of a despotic leader. In Burmese the saying goes " a single rotten Nga-khone-ma (a worthless fish) can spoil a healthy catch"
It is time for the other generals to think of saving their beloved army. Remember how the Romanian Army saved itself from the hands of the despotic Causescu.

timothy Wrote:
14/07/2009
Than Shwe is a pathological liar. None of the global citizens believe what the puppet ambassador announced at UN. That ambassador might be a criminal. The UN chief should know that Than Shwe is telling a packs of lie in UN.





Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

More Articles in This Section


bullet Authorities Threaten Violence at Rangoon Strike

bullet End of February Deadline for BGF

bullet Eggs Withdrawn at Markets after Flu Outbreak

bullet Returning Karen Refugees Fear Landmines

bullet Burmese Navy Participates in Asia-Pacific War Games

bullet Celebrating Shan National Day

bullet Burmese Rock Star-Journalist Wins International Award

bullet International Lawyers Question Thailand's Security Law

bullet Karen Refugees Warned Not To Talk

bullet Thai-Burmese Border Camps Braced for New Refugee Flow


 

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.