Comments for ညရဲ႕ ၀ိညာဥ္၊ အလင္း အေမွာင္နဲ႔ ႀကီးျမင့္ေစာ at http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur , comment 1 to 21 out of 20 comments http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur Thu, 11 Mar 2010 00:48:29 +0100 FeedCreator 1.7.3 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-10788 ကြ်န္ေတာ္က(၁၉၉ ၀)ရန္ကုန္ ပန္းခ်ီေက်ာင္းဆင္း တေယာက္ပါ။ ဆရ ာရဲ႕[impression]ဆန္ျပီး ဒႆနေတြပါတဲ ႔ပန္းခ်ီကားေ တြျမင္ရတာ၊ ဆာ ေလာင္မႈတခုခု ေျပေျပာက္သြာ းသလိုမ်ိဳး၊ ရင္ထဲမွာ ဟာေနမႈကို တစံုတရာ ျဖည္႔ဆည္း လိုက္သလို မ်ိဳး ထူးထူးျခားျခား ခံစားရပါတယ္။ ေက်းဇူးတင္ပါတယ္ ဆရာနဲ႕ ဧရာဝတီ ခင္ဗ်ား။ - Myo Lwin Sun, 18 Oct 2009 02:11:28 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-10576 Those are good art, I think. If you see as nude, it is nude. If you see as art, it will be. All are names what you give. It is not effect to culture or religion. - No Sun, 11 Oct 2009 11:49:34 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-10300 @ Ko Kyaw Zin Oo 1. I doubt Saya Saw's aim was to be "popular/modern", let alone "following the trends of the west". Like I said before, nude art has been a vital part of realistic art; paintings, sculpture or whatever sort of art that involves humans. 2. He's not being shallow-minded; on the contrary, he's being open-minded by PROMOTING A VITAL PART OF ARTISTRY in our little conservative cage called Burma, where pretty much everyone is afraid of changes and thinking. Have you tried drawing a decent full-body human? Even a comical (NOT cartoonishly disproportionate) one? Try it out. If you don't know body proportions, you'll do as well as a drunk monkey. 3. If you would just think back what you said, Saya Saw WASN'T trying to make traditional Burmese art. If he was, he'd have drawn a princess dancing with an oil lamp. 4. And what's wrong with accepting other people's cultures? A culture, by definition, is basically about what a group of people in a certain location on Earth accept as standard FOR THEM. What makes our culture so sacred? Or different from other cultures? (Don't give me that "We follow Buddhism" excuse. Our history's been as bloody as any other countries'; good kings save people, bad kings kill. And I don't even wanna talk about the years in Burma after 1962...) Do you still think the Norwegians (known as Vikings in early centuries) still sail across oceans to rob other villages? Or that the British are just a race of white-supremacists who keep taking one country or another for Queen Victoria? - A.S.H. Mon, 05 Oct 2009 22:32:40 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-9658 ဧရာ၀တီ သင္႕အား ေက်းဇူးတင္ပါသည္။ - thetpyin Tue, 22 Sep 2009 21:05:20 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-8452 ရိုးရိုးေလးပဲအၾကံေပးပါရေစ။ သူမ်ားလုပ္သလုိလုိက္လုပ္တာ တုိးတတ္တယ္လုိ႔ ဥာဏ္မတိမ္ၾကပါနဲ႔။ ဗမာ့အႏုပညာဟာ ဗမာဆန္ဖုိ႔အေရးၾကီးပါတယ္။ ယာဥ္ေက်းမုွခ်င္းမတူတာကုိ .... - ေက်ာ္ဇင္ဦး Thu, 20 Aug 2009 12:30:20 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-7981 It's up to u, how do u mean when u are watching. The important thing is point of view, attitude of viewing, creater's concern, creater's purpose and to respect the privacy. But i can tell this kind of paintings are classified for our religion, tradition, culture, and are not suitable for people who don't have a wide knowledge or who don't have ability to think right enough or who have a low IQ. And this kind of painting must have significant feature differ from pornography. Even i have a little knowledge of fine art, i welcome his initiative in trying to create this kind of art. Every single people have right to express their feeling, opinion in anyway without causing suffer mentally or physically to every other people. i've found out some words that need to make sure in some comments. Here are some questions - Are u assure every western people are not buddhist or buddhism? , Are u assure this kind of art is a real menace to our dignity, religion, tradition, culture? , why many monks are defeated and going to die in beautiful buddhist country? Feedback are welcome! It's just a comment!:) - Trevor Kyaw Tue, 11 Aug 2009 18:51:28 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-6580 hello...ba ba U kyi myint..i m oakkar shwe(son of u ohn shwe)how r u?...I like ur paint and ur idea.keep ahard...be lucky.. - oakkar shwe(son of U ohm shwe) Sun, 05 Jul 2009 05:45:42 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-6515 International မွာေတာ့ NUDE ပန္းခ်ီ ေရးဆဲြျခင္းဟာ ၾကာခဲ့ပါၿပီ၊ အႏုပညာ မ်က္ေစ့နဲ႕ ၾကည့္တတ္ ျမင္တတ္ဖို႔ဘဲ လိုတာပါ။ - thanlwinaung Fri, 03 Jul 2009 12:30:34 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-6198 we should be revolutionary against our old traditional ideas and thoughts. As the artist says, nude figure is the basic of drawing human figure. We should look in the eyes of arts. There is nothing against Buddhism for drawing nude painting. we should abandon our obsolete way of thinkings and go abroad with the flow of globalization. my private opinion even though it is not concerned with arts, we need catalyst who can initiate the change because we, myanmar people, love following the already accustomed environment, ideas, and ways of doing. Thats why we are content with what junta is doing and what we are suffering. In this age, we should get rid of some of our old useless traditions and customs, and ideologies. there is nothing we can lose by adapting new ideas and thoughts. wish myanmar people were broad-minded, and revolutionary. - surfer Fri, 26 Jun 2009 02:01:50 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-5918 ဆရာႀကီးရဲ႕ Nude ပန္းခ်ီကားေတြက ၾကည့္တတ္ယင္ ျမင္မယ္ မၾကည့္တတ္ယင္ မျမင္မယ့္ အျပင္ ပုုဏား (၆)ေယာက္ရဲ႕ အျမင္မ်ိဳး ျဖစ္မယ္ေလ. အႏုုပညာမ်က္စိနဲ႕ ၾကည့္တတ္မွ အႏုုပညာရဲ႕ နက္ရိူင္းမူ႕ကိုု သိေစမယ့္အျပင္ ဖန္တီးရွင္ရဲ႕ စိတ္ခံစားမူ႕ကိုုပါ ထပ္ဆင့္ သိျမင္နိုုင္မွာ ျဖစ္တဲ့ အေၾကာင္း သံုုးသပ္ ထင္ျမင္မိပါတယ္.. - yesa kyo Sat, 20 Jun 2009 02:49:03 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-5657 To understand human figure thoroughly, we have to look at it with no clothes on and draw. There's no other way around. It's only for art's sake. Porn is shameless, but artistic nude is neat. Everyone should respect the work of both models and artist even if you don't like nude painting. It's not an easy work. - Sap Fri, 12 Jun 2009 12:44:47 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-5614 For one thing, nudity is the BASIC of art involving people. Why? Because it's about OUTLINES and PROPORTIONS of a person. Trust me, I recently started learning to draw, and I know enough about how important these are. Without those, you can't draw people well enough. And what's wrong with the paintings anyway? People think it's shameful because of exhibiting nudity? Then we might as well start calling doctors and teachers in medicine school , who KNOW the human body from head to toe, shameless people. Or how about ALL the married couples in the world, who KNOW nudity WELL ENOUGH... Or how about calling OURSELVES, who were ALL born nude? And before people start calling this "Pornography" again, think about its definition... Porn is media used to raise sexual desire/arousal in a user. This is just well-intentioned art. LEARN. THE. BLOODY. DIFFERENCE! Well, of course, if someone feels aroused from looking at Saya Myint's paintings... then it's not Saya's fault. - A.S.H. Thu, 11 Jun 2009 11:45:05 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-5428 အနုပညာကို ဖန္တီးတဲ့ေနရာမွာ လူေတြကမိမိတို ့ရဲ ့ခံစားခ်က္မ်ိဳးစံုကို ခံစားတင္ျပၾကပါတယ္။ ဒါေပမဲ့ တင္ျပဖို ့သင့္ေတာ္တာနဲ ့ မသင့္ေတာ္ဘူးဆိုတဲ့ အပိုင္းနွစ္ခုကိုခြဲျခားထားဖို ့ စည္းကမ္း သတ္မွတ္ထားဖို ့လိုမယ္ထင္ပါတယ္။ အေနာက္နိဳင္ငံသားေတြ အနုပညာဖန္တီးျပသပံုနဲ ့ ျမန္မာ လူမ်ိဳးတို ့ရဲ ့အနုပညာဖန္တီး ျပသပံုကိုနိဳင္းယွဥ္လို ့မရပါဘူး ဘာေၾကာင့္လဲဆိုေတာ့ အေနာက္နိုင္ငံ သားေတြဟာ ဗုဒၡဘာသာ၀င္ေတြ မဟုတ္ၾကသလို အရာရာကို စည္းလြတ္ေဘာင္လြတ္ လုပ္ၾကရင္ေတာင္ မွ ဘာသာေရးနဲ ့ထိခိုက္မူ ့တစံုတရာမျဖစ္နိဳင္ပါဘူး။ ျမန္မာလူမ်ိဳးေတြ မွာကေတာ့ ဘာသာတရား အသက္ အရြယ္နဲ ့ယဥ္ေက်းမူ ့လူ ့စည္းကမ္းေတြက အကန္ ့အသတ္ေတြရွိပါတယ္။ ျမန္မာလူမ်ိဳးေတြရဲ ့ဂုဏ္သိကၡာကို ထိပါးေစမဲ့ အနုပညာကေတာ့ မသင့္ေတာ္ဘူးဆိုတာကို အသက္အရြယ္အားျဖင့္ ေသာ္၄င္း ဘာသာတရားအား ျဖင့္ေသာ္၄င္း သိသင့္တယ္လို ့ထင္ပါတယ္။ ယခုတင္ျပထားတဲ့ပံုေတြဟာ ယဥ္ေက်းမူ ့နဲ ့ေနထိုင္လိုတဲ့ျမန္မာအမ်ိဳး သမီးေတြကို တနည္းအားျဖင့္အရွက္ရေစပါတယ္။ - BW Mon, 08 Jun 2009 16:25:24 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-5409 Hi..sayar gyi..Really appreciate that u have done the good job. You may have express your self in your Art differently..But by creating any sort of things in life we need to be responsible..Life is about discovering..nothing going to be stop u by u r being passionate doing your stuff..unless u die than 'full stop'. Who knows this art that is going to make someone life change? Everyone has the differnt perception so be it..There is no right or no wrong. well done Sayar Gyi.. - Responsible. Mon, 08 Jun 2009 05:37:31 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-4617 ေရးတဲ့သူကလဲ သူ႕ခံစားခ်က္နဲ႕သူေရးၿပီးပါၿပီ။ အဓိက ကေတာ့ ၾကည့္တဲ့သူရဲ႕ အျမင္ပါပဲ။ ဘယ္လုိ ခံစားခ်က္မ်ိဳးနဲ႕ ၾကည့္လဲ။ ဒါပါပဲ။ ရတဲ့ ရသ ကြာျခားပါတယ္။ တကယ္က Porn နဲ႕ ဖုိင္းအတ္ ကြာပါတယ္။ အပုံၾကီးကြာပါတယ္။ အႏုပညာနဲ႕ တဏွာ ကြာပါတယ္။ - ပန္းခ်ီခ်စ္သူ Sun, 24 May 2009 04:06:26 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-4178 အႏုပညာရွင္ တစ္ေယာက္ အေနနဲ ့ သမာရိုးက်ထဲကေန ေဖာက္ထြက္ၿပီး လူေတြေရွ ့ ခ်ျပရဲတာကို ဘာသာေရးေတြ၊ လူမႈေရးေတြ နဲ ့ေတာ့ မကန္ ့သတ္ၾကပါနဲ ့ဗ်ာ။ ကၽြန္ေတာ္တို ့ တိုင္းျပည္မွာ ဒါေတြနဲ ့ပဲ သူမ်ား ေနာက္ က်န္ရစ္ခဲ့ရၿပီ။ အႏုပညာကို အႏုပညာ အျမင္နဲ ့ပဲ ၾကည့္ၾကတာေပါ့။ ပန္းခ်ီဆရာရဲ ့ ထူးခၽြန္မႈေတြ အတြက္ လက္ခုပ္ တီးၾကတာေပါ့။ ဘဘရဲ ့ပံုေတြ မွာ ပါတဲ့ မိန္းမေတြ ရဲ ့မ်က္ႏွာေတြ၊ သံုးထားတဲ့ အေရာင္ေတြ၊ အလင္း အေမွာင္ ေပးထားတာေတြဟာ သူဘာကို ေျပာျပခ်င္လဲ ဆိုတာ ေပၚလြင္ပါတယ္ဗ်ာ။ အင္တာဗ်ဴးထဲမွာ လဲ ေျပာျပထားတာပဲ။ ဘဘရဲ ့ကားသစ္ ေတြ နဲ ့ အင္တာဗ်ဴးကို ဖတ္လုိက္ရတဲ့ အတြက္ ေက်းဇူး တင္ပါတယ္ဧရာ၀တီ။ - ZEAL Wed, 20 May 2009 10:29:32 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-3936 Although his purpose is for only create and feel for his art, what is the advatages for people? He should create and use his skill in other way for the young generation. If we encourage like this pictures, later everybody can see everywhere even in public areas of Myanmar. I don't mean that his art is not nice, quite nice and respect on his art but misuse. We are Buddhist Country. If myanmar people start to break the buddha's laws , who will keep in future? - Vee Sat, 16 May 2009 16:46:48 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-3571 be aware it is not good in the relogious point of view. we're Buddhist and the beautiful Buddhist country in the world. He is quite old and if he has the sense, he shouldnt do that. especially the portrait of many ladies. - a kyaw Wed, 13 May 2009 14:47:12 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-3527 Please keep up the good work. Don't give up ! This is a kind of revolution in arts history of Burma. You are the revolutionary leader. Please don't let down the cause. - Saya Lay Tue, 12 May 2009 16:55:52 +0100 http://www.irrawaddy.org/bur/index.php/interview/4-interview/1044-2009-05-08-12-15-58#comment-3489 အဲဒီ Nude ေမာ္ဒယ္ မူရင္း ဓာတ္ပံုေတြဟာ အျပင္မွာ ျပန္႔ထြက္လာျပီး ပြန္ဆိုဒ္ေတြေပၚ တက္သြားတာေတာ့ မလိုလားတဲ့ ထိခိုက္မႈေတြ ျဖစ္ေစတယ္ ထင္ပါတယ္။ ေရးျပီးရင္ ဓာတ္ပံုေတြကို ဖ်က္ဆီးပစ္တာမ်ိဳး လုပ္သင့္တယ္ ထင္ပါတယ္။ - သင္ကာ Sun, 10 May 2009 14:27:59 +0100