SUBSCRIBE|ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION




NEWS ANALYSIS

Ban Should Now Tackle Burma’s Constitution, Says Opposition


By WAI MOE Wednesday, July 15, 2009

COMMENTS (5)
RECOMMEND (13)
E-MAIL
PRINT

Opposition parties in Burma say UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon didn’t go far enough in urging the military regime to ensure that the 2010 general election is “credible, inclusive and legitimate.”

The UN chief should also have addressed demands to rewrite the constitution drawn up by the regime and enacted in 2008, they say.

Nyan Win, spokesman of the National League for Democracy (NLD), said that even if the 2010 election were to be “free and fair”—as the regime had promised—“the 2008 constitution is undemocratic.”

The NLD disagreed with Ban on this point, Nyan Win said.

The regime claimed the 2008 constitution had been approved by more than 90 percent of voters in a national referendum held shortly after the Cyclone Nargis in May that year. Critics say the constitution had been drafted by handpicked official representatives and that the referendum was anything but free and fair.

The constitution reserves 25 percent of seats in both houses of a new parliament for military representatives, appointed by the commander-in-chief of the armed forces.

It also bars any person married to a foreigner from serving as president of the country. Furthermore, presidents must have military experience.

Both restrictions rule out the possibility of Aung San Suu Kyi ever taking office. “Daw Aung San Suu Kyi is definitely banned from becoming president under the 2008 constitution,” Nyan Win said. 

Burma’s largest ceasefire groups—the Wa, Kachin, Kokang and Mon—also take issue with the constitution, which reserves 25 percent of the seats in state or regional assemblies for non-elected military representatives. The commander-in-chief of the armed forces will have power to abolish the parliaments of ethnic states and autonomous regions. 

In a joint letter to the Chinese government, Wa and Kachin leaders said they wanted the 2008 constitution amended because it failed to respect the truth of political history and perpetuated the Burman centric long-term political distrust towards ethnic minorities.

“Mr Ban Ki-moon’s election proposals are totally out of touch with stakeholders in Burmese politics,” said Aye Thar Aung, an Arakan leader and secretary of the Arakan League for Democracy. “The greatest difficulty for Burma’s democracy process is now the constitutional crisis.”

Aye Thar Aung said the UN’s Burma efforts should now be directed at making sure the constitution enshrined democratic principles and ethnic minority rights.



COMMENTS (5)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

Taung Paw Kachin Wrote:
18/07/2009
This 2008 constitution is just a mess to trash in the dust bin. No ethnic group with their right minds will accept it as a legitimate one. Even much better ones from 1947 and 1974 caused dissatisfaction among ethnic minorities. This one will make the real split of the country.

Moe Aung Wrote:
16/07/2009
The prevailing ideology interprets democracy as little more than free and fair elections, so Ban gets fixated on the 2010 sham elections on the basis of half a loaf is better than nothing. The shameful farce that was the 2008 constitution is deemed a fait accompli, and somehow he hopes to manage the next stage.

A dictatorship is a fait accompli after a coup, and recognized as a de facto government. It retains its membership in the UN. How do we review/reverse that?

We know the answer. Only it's unthinkable to those committed to non-violence regardless of the nature of the monster we are facing. The outcome is therefore predictable - ISQ. The nightmare that is Burmese life is set to continue until we get yet another rude awakening only to fall back into this horrible incubus.

George Than Setkyar Heine Wrote:
16/07/2009
“Mr Ban Ki-moon’s election proposals are totally out of touch with stakeholders in Burmese politics,” said Aye Thar Aung, an Arakan leader and “The greatest difficulty for Burma’s democracy process is now the constitutional crisis.”

This is the crux of the matter at hand today.
It is certain that not only NLD but also the people of Burma and global community will not accept the military enshrined constitution as a basis for Burma's future, as it lacks freedom and democratic ideals as desired by all.

And Ban Ki-moon has been mentioning holding free and fair elections in Burma until today.
This self-testimony to the South Korean's failure to grasp the most fundamental point in the crucial criteria indispensable in putting Burma on a free and democratic road.

Hence Burma's agony will continue like the military rule he is offering to help prolong as long as he holds UN's helm on the same course.

We are talking about freedom and democracy in Burma today, not prolonging military rule, lest the South Korean forgets.

Kyi May Kaung Wrote:
16/07/2009
The NLD is absolutely right. THe UN should not keep talking as if 2010 "election" is OK.

Do we forget so fast about 2008 referendum held while the country was reeling under Cyclone Nargis?

The UN is responsible -- even before 08 it kept talking (and promoting) 2010 as if it were legitimate.

Why does everyone have so much trouble calling it the farce it is?

Kyi May Kaung.

George Than Setkyar Heine Wrote:
15/07/2009
Now they are talking! Since day one the 2010 elections based on military dominated constitution were doomed.Gambari never talked about it. And his South Korean boss only mentioned about fair and inclusive elections in 2010 whenever he met Than Shwe and his thugs.

People are blind to the crux of the matter - military enshrined constitution - which really spells disaster for Burma's future in the first place.

Not only it was drawn unilaterally by Than Shwe and his thugs but also endorsed forcibly in the aftermath of Cyclone Nargis, where more than 140,000 people died and millions were left homeless.

With the military enshrined constitution still in place, participating or winning the elections even would serve only to legitimize military rule in Burma on the part of NLD and others.

Maung Aye and his men are pushing Than Shwe out of the political picture in Burma.
He is turning to Buddha for help, but this will be to no avail for he ordered the killing of monks and made many lives miserable.





Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

More Articles in This Section


bullet Children’s Rights Celebrated in Naypyidaw

bullet US Calls for Dialogue between Suu Kyi and Junta

bullet UN Passes Resolutions on Burma Human Rights

bullet Myint Swe: The Tatmadaw’s Next Top Dog?

bullet Handcuffed Statue Has the Experts Talking

bullet ‘Burma VJ’ Short-listed for Oscar

bullet Assessing the US-Asean Summit

bullet Coco Islands to Open for Tourism

bullet Global Fund Returns to Burma with Large Grant

bullet Mystery of the Handcuffed Statues


 

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.