SUBSCRIBE|ADVERTISE | DONATION
Irrawaddy CONTACT US|FAQ
BURMESE VERSION




Burmese Armed Forces Day Celebrated in Naypyidaw


By MIN LWIN Friday, March 27, 2009

COMMENTS (19)
RECOMMEND (123)
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
 
MORE
E-MAIL
PRINT

The 64th anniversary of Armed Forces Day was observed on Friday in Naypyidaw with the troops on parade before high-ranking members of the junta.

The 400,000-man army, navy and air force, called the tatmadaw, is one of the most battle-tested forces in Southeast Asia, having engaged ongoing armed Communist insurgents and armed ethnic separatist armies for more than six decades.

Burmese soldiers march in formation during the 64th anniversary Armed Forces Day held at the parade ground in the country's administrative capital Naypyidaw on March 27. (Photo: AP)
Since the 1988 pro-democracy uprising, the Burmese generals have doubled the size of the armed forces, now the most dominant and strongest institution in the country.

“In 1988, the army had not more than 180,000 armed personnel, but nowadays it reaches more than 400,000 personnel,” said Aung Kyaw Zaw, a Chinese-based Burmese researcher.

He said that although Burma has upgraded its military arsenal, it has not produced high quality military commanders since the military seized power in 1988 and it suffers from low morale among the troops.

“They have formed many battalions, but a battalion has decreased in the number of personnel,” he said.

About 200 troops make up a battalion in the Burmese army.

The military has a tradition of religious and racial discrimination in the promotion of officers, according to analysts.

Burma's No. 3 leader, Gen Thura Shwe Mann, top right, speaks at the award giving ceremony held after the parade show at the 64th anniversary of Armed Forces Day. (Photo: AP)
Defense scholar Maung Aung Myoe said there was no discrimination on racial or religious grounds in the military until the mid-1990s; Christian officers, for example, were appointed to senior staff and command positions.

Since then, however, religion and race appear to be important criteria. Although there is no official regulation, non-Buddhist officers or officers with non-Buddhist spouses are unlikely to climb beyond the rank of major or hold important command position, noted the defense scholar.

“If your spouse is a non-Buddhist, you will be sacked,” one retired captain who now works as a security officer in a hotel in Rangoon told The Irrawaddy.

The Burmese military faces problems of low morale among its forces, and the desertion rate is a concern.

Defense scholar Maung Aung Myoe quoted a confidential report that said between May and August 2006, a total of 9,467 desertions were reported; 7,761 desertions were reported between January and April 2000. Some estimates claim that the tatmadaw has a monthly average desertion rate 1,600 troops.

A retired army officer said, “The tatmadaw has low morale, especially in army.”

“Officers are involved in taking money from illegal trading in their areas,” he said. “While high-ranking Burmese military officers become wealthier, pay for ordinary soldiers at the bottom is below-standard.”

The officer-level morale is high, he said, partly because they earn more than civil servants, and they are given other benefits such as trips abroad to study on scholarships.

Even though the Burmese army is Southeast Asia’s second largest military force, it has many financial and logistic difficulties.

Maung Aung Myo said the air force is still very limited in its ability to project power. Problems include a shortage of trained pilots to fly existing aircraft, especially advanced aircraft such as the MiG-29.



COMMENTS (19)
 
Please read our policy before you post comments. Click here
Name:
E-mail:   (Your e-mail will not be published.)
Comment:
You have characters left.
Word Verification: captcha Type the characters you see in the picture.
 

Moe Aung Wrote:
13/04/2009
Hla Oo,

"It (the army) is an revered institution and it will always be, especially when it marches back into the barracks!"

Your frustration and at the same time sympathy with the army as an veteran of the same institution is understandable. Your last bit - when they return to the barracks - now there's the rub. The sham 2008 constitution provides both explicit and implicit indications that no such intention exists. On the contrary, they've made sure they can never be shown the door.

If they are serious about remaining the "people's army," or rather even restoring a modicum of trust in them, they have a hell of a job on their hands. And as things stand and are shaping in Burma, there's only one way to do it - rise up together with the people and overthrow the generals who have usurped, abused and degraded the "revered institution." Or it will be too late for any chance of redemption.

The three sons - students, sangha, and soldiers - must now come together for the people.

Hla Oo Wrote:
11/04/2009
The Burmese Army has been a people's army since the beginning and it will always be for the people of Burma, us, as it should always be.

It's just going through a rather long bad patch, unfortunately, because of the long-running civil war and Ne Win's and Than Shwe's countless bad decisions.

Once we have a reasonably fair democracy and a prosperous economy and a peaceful society, the army will become the people's army again like the armies of Indonesia, the Philippines and Thailand.

Nobody owns the army, not even Aung San, let alone Ne Win or Than Shwe. Our fathers started it, we served in it, and now our children are serving in it for our country.

It has been built with the blood, sweat, and tears of at least three generations of Burmese, whether they are Burmans or the ethnics.

It is an revered institution and it will always be, especially when it marches back into the barracks!

Moe Aung Wrote:
03/04/2009
I wonder if Okkar is the same Okkar who has contributed a great deal to Myanmar Army-related articles in the English Wikipedia. Only putting two and two together.

naingmya Wrote:
02/04/2009
Standing and shouting slogans in front of embassies is the culture of the opposition groups. These guys shoot their own photos and use them to apply for asylum in the West. They can’t cheat anymore when the US and Burma set up a strong relationship. Welcome to the new chapter of our friendship.

KKK Wrote:
02/04/2009
Okkar: Killing every innocent Burmese citizen has become a culture for the generals. How dare you accuse our independence leader, General Aung San! You're just like your fathers (generals).

Moe Aung Wrote:
02/04/2009
Okkar predictably blames Aung San to defend his generals. Dead men tell no tales. Nor can they defend themselves. Bravo!

Plan B worries about a revolt within the ranks and takes pains to assure us that's never going to happen. Reminds me of the proverbial concern of the wife of the Minister for Elephants. Or is it the parrot and Me Baw?

What are generals without an army? What are officers without troops? Paper tigers.

Let's not squabble about the fighting skills and courage of the troops. Let's win them over to the side of the people. It is incumbent upon all of us to work ceaselessly on our friends and family/relatives in the army to join the people and overthrow the generals.

Come the fire next time, People Power will have real teeth to fight back, “sword against sword, spear against spear,” as Ne Win once infamously said after he'd massacred unarmed students and blown up the union building.

Let's pull the rug from under them. Students, monks and soldiers must come together. Make it happen.

Okkar Wrote:
31/03/2009
Blaming someone else has become a culture for the Burmese opposition. Aung San fathered the child that is the Tatmadaw. He ran away to follow his dream instead of helping to bring up his child. His fatherless child grew up with a stepfather who behaved badly, and people pointed their fingers at the stepfather. In reality, Aung San is equally guilty for being a bad leader of the Tatmadaw. Just because he is dead, that does not make him a blameless saint.

Jim San Wrote:
31/03/2009
Okkar doesn't understand who is father of the army. Clearly, all of our Burmese students are founders/fathers of the army. Bad sons come up because Ne Win, Than Shwe and all SPDC members are bad sons of the students. Why they're bad sons is because they aren’t educated and their thinking is still limited to the 8th century.

U Saw Oo Wrote:
30/03/2009
"It [the Tatmadaw] has not produced high quality military commanders since the military seized power in 1988" is spot on because the military does not provide an environment for smart brains to thrive. I've seen officers naming themselves "stones," which in Burmese is "Kyuk-Tone," meaning "becoming idiots because of fear."

Okkar Wrote:
30/03/2009
It is important for everyone to remember who founded the army. Aung San was a founding member of the army, but immediately after the war, he went on to get involved in politics. Ne Win was left to look after the army and re-organize it. So in a true sense, it is Ne Win who is the father of the army, not Aung San.

Maybe all the ills of the Tatmadaw started with Ne Win because he was a bad stepfather. Aung San should be blamed for neglecting the army in pursuit of his political career. He was much like a father who didn't want to take responsibility for his children, like a student who ran away after finding out his girlfriend is pregnant. If Aung San did stay in the army and bring it up according to his principles, none of this would have happened. All in all, both Aung San and Ne Win are bad fathers and equally responsible for fathering bad sons in the Tatmadaw. So there's nothing wrong in bad sons killing bad fathers. It's a vicious circle!

Yang Sai Wrote:
30/03/2009
Who founded the Burmese army? Or who is the father of the Burmese army? Don't say Aung San. Let's say the Burmese students founded that army and were father of that too—because Aung San himself was one of those Burmese students.

At that time, if those students hadn't understood the country's conditions well and hadn't founded the Burmese army, the army would not exist today. So, we're simply the fathers of Than Shwe and the members of SPDC. Than Shwe has to understand that.

Than Shwe has to obey our orders. Than Shwe himself wasn’t a student. Killing Burmese students by the Burmese army means killing their own fathers. It also makes sense that in no way will Burmese students give up their determination since they themselves founded the army. All members of the SPDC have to understand that, since they're all our sons.

Su Su Wrote:
30/03/2009
The Burmese army today is there just to protect high-ranking members of the junta and their families. They can't do anything good for the people of Burma. If you did a poll on how the Burmese view the soldiers, at least 99 percent of the people would surely say that those soldiers are killers of our own people and monks. How pitiful our army and our people are. So, this is the right time for our own people and our army to coordinate and oust the high-ranking members of the junta from their seats and build our country together.

Than Shwe Naing Wrote:
30/03/2009
Than Shwe doesn't know anything about the country. What he knows is just how to feed his family and his stupid brothers-in-law. All his family members are stupid and have made the country poorer and poorer, while they become richer.

Than Zin Wrote:
29/03/2009
Knowing that Burma has the 12th largest army in the world and one of the poorest countries in the world, we should know that the junta is lying all the time.

zin zin Wrote:
29/03/2009
Does Than Shwe have any brain, saying nonsense again and again?

Zaw Min Wrote:
28/03/2009
The regime built up the military in the same way as the country was built, on falsified statistics and numbers without real progress. What good is a military armed to the teeth when individual soldiers and commanders are selected for dumbly following orders like a fascist military? And are arms bought by generals lining their pocket with kickback money good enough to really do the job they are intended for?

Starving soldiers and crooked commanders rob and steal from the people they are supposed to protect. Commanders bravely sneer and laugh when ordering soldiers to attack unarmed demonstrators and monks in the cities but are afraid to face similarly or even less heavily armed rebels because they are afraid of the arms the rebels as well as their own soldiers are holding, knowing both can turn be turned against them.

Such is the situation of our mighty army—waiting for a crisis, to fall in defeat and disgrace like the Russian Czar’s army in World War I.

Yang Sai Wrote:
28/03/2009
Than Shwe's address was stupid. He still doesn't know anything about the country. He still needs to read 9th century political books since his knowledge is so limited to 8th century thinking.

shwe Moe Wrote:
28/03/2009
The 400,000-man army, navy and air force, called the Tatmadaw, is one of the most battle-tested forces in Southeast Asia, having engaged ongoing armed Communist insurgents and armed ethnic separatist armies for more than six decades.

This army would not stand a chance if there were a serious conflict. It is an army without a soul, an army that is in conflict within itself, in its rank and file, which is why it cannot win the ethnic battles even with the best equipment in the world.

If a picture is worth a thousand words, the Burmese Army tells it all.


plan B Wrote:
28/03/2009
Beware—underestimating the unity of the Burmese armed force will serve no good other than promote more ridiculous ideas. A thoughtful approach will serve the citizenry better.
Dreaming of a revolt from within should remain just a dream. The legendary loyalty of Burmese troops must be studied. Let's not let the knowledge of their past iniquities overshadow their resolve.








Thailand Hotels
Bangkok Hotels
China Hotels
India Hotels

More Articles in This Section


bullet NDF Leaders Told to Appeal Past Treason Charges

bullet New US Law Could Force PTTEP Disclosure

bullet US Senators Want UN Investigation of Burma

bullet Thai Minister's Statement Spreads Fear in Camps

bullet Burma's Generals Meet North Korea's FM

bullet USDP Constitution Maintains Junta's Policies

bullet USDP Assigns Constituencies to Ministers

bullet NLD Members Meet ILO Representative in Rangoon

bullet Burmese Rank No. 1 in Malaysia Detention Center Deaths

bullet US Wants Burma-North Korea 'Transparency'


 

Home |News |Regional |Business |Opinion |Multimedia |Special Feature |Interview |Magazine |Archives |Research
Copyright © 2008 Irrawaddy Publishing Group. All Rights Reserved.